What is quality of hire?
Quality of hire is a metric that shows how much value new hires bring to a company. It tells you whether hiring brought in people who perform well and stay. It complements speed and cost metrics with the result that matters most.
Why quality of hire matters
Time to hire and cost per hire measure how fast and how expensive hiring is. They don’t tell you whether the company hired the right person. Fast and cheap hiring is worth little if the new hire leaves after three months.
Quality of hire adds the outcome. It helps you see which candidate sources, selection methods and recruiters bring in people who succeed.
How to measure quality of hire
| Indicator | What it measures | Where to get it |
|---|---|---|
| Performance rating | How well the new hire does the job. | The manager’s rating after probation or after a year. |
| Retention | Whether the new hire stayed. | The share of new hires still employed after a year. |
| Ramp-up time | How quickly the person works independently. | Days until the onboarding goals are met. |
| Hiring manager satisfaction | Whether the manager got the person they needed. | A short survey for the hiring manager. |
| Probation | Whether the employment ended during probation. | HR system data. |
Choose two to four indicators you have reliable data for. More indicators don’t make the result more accurate.
Quality of hire formula and example
A common approach is to convert each indicator into a percentage and take the average.
Example calculation
A company hired ten people last year. It now measures three indicators:
| Indicator | Result | As a percentage |
|---|---|---|
| Average performance rating | 4 out of 5 | 80% |
| Retention after one year | 9 out of 10 people | 90% |
| Hiring manager satisfaction | 7 out of 10 | 70% |
Quality of hire is (80 + 90 + 70) ÷ 3 = 80%. The number alone says little. The comparison between periods, roles and candidate sources is what matters.
Why quality of hire is hard to measure
- Results come late. Performance and retention are known only after months.
- Data sits in different systems. Hiring data is in the ATS, performance ratings in the HR system. See HRIS vs ATS.
- Ratings are subjective. Every manager rates differently. A shared scale helps.
- Small numbers. With few hires a year, one person can change the result a lot.
How to improve quality of hire
- Be clear about who you need. A competency model and a thorough briefing with the hiring manager help.
- Structure interviews. The same questions and the same rating scale for every candidate.
- Test skills. Tests and practical tasks tell you more than a CV.
- Show the job honestly. A candidate who knows what to expect can make a better decision.
- Track sources. Find out which channels bring people who succeed, for example an employee referral program.
- Take care of the start. Good onboarding helps new hires get up to speed and stay.
Quality of hire and RECRU
RECRU keeps your hiring data in one place: the candidate source, the progress through the hiring process and test results. Reports show your team’s performance, candidates and jobs for a selected time frame.
Performance after the start date usually lives in the HR system. You can export RECRU data to CSV with the columns you need and combine it with performance and retention data.
RECRU is a cloud service you can try free for 14 days.
Frequently asked questions
Is quality of hire a KPI?
Yes, it is one of the main recruiting KPIs. It is most useful together with time to hire and cost per hire.
When should you measure quality of hire?
The end of probation gives you the first data. A rating after one year gives a more reliable picture, because both performance and retention are known.
What is the difference between quality of hire and employee turnover?
Employee turnover measures how many employees leave across the company. Quality of hire focuses on new hires and looks at their performance as well as retention.
Can you measure quality of hire for a single role?
Yes, but the result is only indicative. It is better to track groups of similar roles over a longer period.
Subscribe To Our
HR Newsletter
Stay updated and get the latest scoop on HR topics.
We care about your data in our privacy policy