What is a hiring manager?
A hiring manager is the person who needs to fill a role in their team and decides who gets it. In most cases, they become the new hire’s direct manager. They define the requirements for the role, run the technical interviews and choose the candidate with the recruiter. It is a role in a hiring process, not a job title.
Who can be a hiring manager?
Any manager who is hiring for their own team: a store manager, a head of engineering or the owner of a small business. What matters is that they will work with the new person and are accountable for the hiring decision.
In job ads and recruiting software, the term is used across industries and company sizes. The hiring manager changes with every role, while the recruiter often runs many hiring processes at once.
What does a hiring manager do?
| Hiring stage | Hiring manager’s task |
|---|---|
| Brief | Describes who they need, why and the salary budget. |
| Job ad | Checks that the job description matches reality. |
| Shortlisting | Gives the recruiter feedback on the first profiles. |
| Interviews | Runs the technical round and tests skills. |
| Decision | Chooses the candidate and approves the offer. |
| Start | Prepares the first days and the onboarding of the new hire. |
Hiring manager vs recruiter: what is the difference?
| Area | Hiring manager | Recruiter |
|---|---|---|
| Main goal | Choose the right person for the team. | Bring in suitable candidates and run the process. |
| Knows best | The work, the team and what the role really requires. | The job market, candidate sources and the hiring process. |
| Decides | Whom to hire. | Who moves on to the next round. |
| Hiring is | One of many responsibilities. | The core of the job. |
Neither can do it alone. A recruiter without a clear brief is searching blind. A hiring manager without a recruiter has neither the candidates nor the time for the whole process.
How should the hiring manager work with the recruiter?
Collaboration starts with an intake meeting. Half an hour is enough, and it is worth agreeing on five things.
- Must-haves and nice-to-haves. Two or three requirements that are non-negotiable. Everything else is a bonus.
- Salary and conditions. The range the recruiter can share with candidates.
- Hiring process. How many rounds there will be and who will run them.
- Timeline. When the person should start and when the manager wants to see the first candidates.
- Feedback. How many days the manager needs to respond to each profile.
Speed matters. A candidate who waits a week for feedback will accept another offer in the meantime. Agree on a feedback deadline and stick to it.
Common hiring manager mistakes
- Unclear brief. Requirements change during the interviews.
- Slow feedback. Profiles sit in the inbox and candidates drop out.
- Looking for the perfect candidate. Nobody on the market meets the whole list.
- Too many rounds. Every extra round makes hiring longer and puts some candidates off.
- Unprepared interviews. Each candidate gets different questions and they cannot be compared.
From practice
In recruitment agencies, the client plays the hiring manager role. The same applies: the faster the client responds to candidates, the better the chance of filling the role. RECRU’s solution for agencies is on the recruitment agencies page.
Hiring managers in RECRU
RECRU has a dedicated environment for hiring managers and agency clients, the hiring manager zone. Recruiters use it to share candidates and collect feedback, including via chat. Hiring managers see the progress of hiring for their roles in real time and can submit requests for new hiring processes directly in RECRU. The recruiter decides what each manager can see.
RECRU is a cloud service you can try free for 14 days.
Frequently asked questions
Is a hiring manager the same as an HR manager?
No. An HR manager runs the HR department. A hiring manager is a manager from any department who is currently hiring for their own team.
Who has the final say?
Usually the hiring manager, because they will work with the new person. HR and the recruiter make sure the process is fair, candidates get the same conditions and the offer stays within agreed limits.
Can the business owner be the hiring manager?
Yes. In a small company, this is the case for most roles. The owner then often does the recruiter’s job as well.
What is an intake meeting?
The kick-off meeting between the recruiter and the hiring manager before a role opens. They agree on requirements, salary, the hiring process and the timeline.
Subscribe To Our
HR Newsletter
Stay updated and get the latest scoop on HR topics.
We care about your data in our privacy policy