What is a candidate shortlist?
A candidate shortlist is a small group of the most suitable candidates that a recruiter or headhunter puts forward to the hiring company for interviews. It comes from a longlist, which is a broader list of people who meet the basic requirements for the role. The hiring manager or client then decides whom to invite next.
What do longlist and shortlist mean?
Both words describe lists of candidates at different stages of hiring. A longlist is long and broad. A shortlist is short and selective. Shortlist is also used as a verb. A shortlisted candidate has made it into the final selection.
The terms are most common in headhunting and in recruitment agencies. The same approach works just as well for in-house hiring.
Longlist vs shortlist
| Area | Longlist | Shortlist |
|---|---|---|
| Size | Dozens of people, fewer for rare roles. | Usually 3 to 5 candidates. |
| Who is on it | People whose profiles meet the basic requirements. | Candidates who passed a first conversation and are interested in the role. |
| What you know | Experience, education and skills from a profile or CV. | Also motivation, salary expectations, notice period and the recruiter’s assessment. |
| Who uses it | The recruiter or headhunter. | The hiring manager or client. |
How to build a longlist
- Brief. Agree with the client or hiring manager which requirements are essential and which are nice to have.
- Market mapping. Find out which companies and roles these people work in.
- Search. Go through your own database, LinkedIn, referrals and responses to your job ad.
- First screening. Remove people who don’t meet the essential requirements.
How a longlist becomes a shortlist
The recruiter contacts people on the longlist and holds a first conversation with those who are interested. They check experience, motivation, salary expectations and notice period. Only candidates they would personally recommend make the shortlist.
Each shortlisted candidate comes with a short summary. Why they fit, what attracts them to the role, what the risks are and when they can start. The hiring manager doesn’t have to read dozens of CVs.
A shortlist without summaries is just a shorter list. Write two or three sentences on why you recommend each candidate. Decisions will be faster and feedback more specific.
Common mistakes
- A shortlist that is too long. Ten names is not a shortlist. The hiring manager will get lost.
- A vague brief. Without agreed essentials, the longlist cannot be narrowed down.
- Candidates who aren’t interested. Only people who want the role belong on the shortlist.
- Slow feedback. While the company takes weeks to decide, good candidates accept other offers.
Shortlists, longlists and RECRU
For executive search, RECRU lets you share longlists with clients through the client portal. Clients review the candidates, and their decision and comments appear in RECRU immediately. The client portal comes at no extra cost.
When you build a longlist, the AI agent helps search LinkedIn and your own database. The LinkedIn plugin shows what percentage a profile matches your open roles.
RECRU is a cloud service you can try free for 14 days.
Frequently asked questions
How many candidates should be on a shortlist?
Usually 3 to 5. Fewer gives the company little choice, more slows down the decision. For very rare roles, a shortlist of two can be fine.
What does shortlisted mean?
A shortlisted candidate has been selected for the final round of the hiring process, usually interviews with the hiring manager or client.
Who creates the shortlist?
A recruiter, headhunter or recruitment agency. The hiring manager or client decides whom to hire from it.
Is a shortlist the same as a longlist?
No. The longlist comes first and is much broader. The shortlist is the small group of the best candidates selected from it.
Subscribe To Our
HR Newsletter
Stay updated and get the latest scoop on HR topics.
We care about your data in our privacy policy